Why All Communists Aren’t Nazis

The website Instapundit, in a recent post, equates communists to Nazis. “Communists are as bad as Nazis,” the post argues, “and their defenders and apologists are as bad as Nazis’ defenders, but far more common. When you meet them, show them no respect. They’re evil, stupid, and dishonest. They should not enjoy the consequences of their behavior.”

The post offers no definition of ‘Communist’. However, its implied definition spans a wide spectrum of philosophies, and includes Marxist academics, the Trotskyite Christopher Hitchens, and Joseph Stalin. The post says, in effect, that all of these people are ‘Communists,’ and therefore equally evil.

I see two flaws with this argument. The first is related to semantics, the second to the logical fallacy of accident.

Semantics

The various people identified above have very different philosophies. A Marxist, strictly speaking, is someone who ascribes to the original writings of Karl Marx.* Interestingly, Marx made very few predictions about what a communist society might look like or how it should be implemented. The bulk of his analysis focused on contemporary economics and the relationship of workers to their labour. Even today, Marx is thought to have made several helpful contributions to the study of capitalism. A Marxist academic, then, typically means a university professor who agrees with Marx’s views on how capitalism operates and how it shapes our society. These people are also called Marxians.

Hitchens and Stalin, on the other hand, are political creatures. Their Marxism is normative, meaning it deals with how society should be organized. Clearly, their concerns are qualitatively different than those of Marxian economists. In addition to that, there is a vast gap between Hitchens’ politics and Stalin’s: Trotsky’s opposition to Stalin is well documented.

Assigning all these people to a single category – Communist – is a serious flaw. It invalidates the Nazi comparison, since a Nazi is someone who holds very specific political and racial beliefs. To say that Stalinists are as morally bankrupt as Nazis is one thing; to say the same about a Marxian is another.

Accident

The Instapundit post says that in all Communist states, “[power] always ends up in the hands of the [elites]” (emphasis mine). In other words, every communist state that ever existed was as awful as Hitler’s Germany; pure evil, basically.** Here, the post commits the fallacy of accident, meaning it ignores obvious exceptions to its assumed rule.

Some Communist regimes – those of Stalin, Mao, etc. – were certainly evil. But others weren’t. The Sandinistas in Nicaragua, for example, lowered illiteracy from 50% to 12% and made important strides in health care, eliminating polio and reducing other diseases. Of course, they were terrible economic managers and are reported to have committed deplorable human rights abuses. But they were not genocidal. The difference between a Sandinista and a National Socialist is enormous.

To add further perspective, consider if this line of argument was deployed against Christianity. The number of Christian states that have committed horrible and inhumane acts is lengthy, yet I assume the Instapundit author would hesitate to equate Christianity to Nazism (Hitchens wouldn’t, though).

Anyways, the point is that it’s both fallacious and meaningless to say that all people who believe in some element of Marxist thought are inherently evil because so too are some Communist regimes.

*And of course Friedrich Engels, too.

** If you think I’m reaching, here’s another excerpt from the Instapundit post: “I’ll repeat: The difference between Communists and Nazis is mostly PR, and the PR is better because more journalists and academics were communists than Nazis.”

6 Replies to “Why All Communists Aren’t Nazis”

  1. Needed to compose you the little remark to say thanks over again with your spectacular principles you have discussed above. This has been certainly strangely generous with people like you to allow easily just what a number of people could possibly have supplied for an e-book to make some profit on their own, certainly since you could have done it if you wanted. The things also acted to be a easy way to know that some people have the identical dreams just like mine to understand significantly more with reference to this problem. I’m sure there are several more fun times in the future for individuals that read your website.

  2. I’m writing to make you know what a perfect experience my cousin’s daughter obtained reading yuor web blog. She came to find numerous details, not to mention what it is like to possess a great giving mindset to let many more clearly thoroughly grasp certain tortuous matters. You really exceeded our own expectations. Thanks for distributing such great, healthy, explanatory not to mention easy tips on this topic to Sandra.

  3. I enjoy you because of all of the effort on this website. Ellie delights in making time for investigation and it’s obvious why. My spouse and i know all of the compelling means you produce invaluable ideas on the blog and therefore increase participation from website visitors on the theme while our favorite child has been starting to learn a lot of things. Enjoy the rest of the year. You are always doing a brilliant job.

  4. I simply had to appreciate you all over again. I’m not certain what I could possibly have done in the absence of the actual techniques discussed by you directly on that theme. It truly was a very alarming situation in my view, nevertheless viewing the professional strategy you managed the issue took me to jump with gladness. I’m just happier for the support as well as pray you know what a powerful job your are accomplishing teaching the others using your site. I know that you’ve never encountered any of us.

  5. I and also my pals appeared to be reading through the nice information and facts on the blog and then suddenly I had a horrible feeling I never thanked you for those strategies. All of the ladies are already as a consequence thrilled to study them and have in effect clearly been taking advantage of those things. We appreciate you being considerably thoughtful and for going for some helpful subject matter millions of individuals are really eager to be aware of. My sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to you earlier.

  6. My spouse and i ended up being very more than happy that Albert could deal with his analysis from your ideas he gained out of your weblog. It is now and again perplexing to simply always be giving freely tricks that people have been selling. And we all consider we now have the website owner to appreciate for this. The illustrations you’ve made, the straightforward web site navigation, the relationships you will help instill – it’s got many remarkable, and it is helping our son in addition to the family believe that that subject matter is enjoyable, which is tremendously mandatory. Many thanks for all!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *